It is not enough to succeed. Others must fail
Gore Vidal
I made a bad call in deciding to ignore the Budget chatter. All sorts of folk were getting worked up about it. Rather than listen to it go out today I spent the time looking at the stones in the header pic -Stanton Drew.
I did wonder if I should have listened to the budget at one time. Those black and white cows decided to get up and charge round the field so I had my back to a stone and needed to stand my ground with a couple of tons of beef heading my way. I observed a couple of pizzles in the herd. But they left me be, though I fancy I felt the ground shake 😉
Ah yes, Budget. Bad call. I get to pay £6k on 30k worth of capital gains on gold rather than 3k. Ho hum.
I do hope the personal allowance gets lifted later on as promised, though I suspect that’ll fall by the wayside. On the upside, some long-standing inquities are finally addressed.
agricultural relief
Many years ago, before I was a nipper, the reforming post-war Labour governments taxed the aristocracy trying to pass on their dynastic wealth given ’em by William the Conk. This was called estate duty (inheritance tax to you and me) . It’s why the National Trust has all those grand buildings. It was all part of the deal after the carnage of the First World war when the proles were slaughtered in the trenches, in fairness the aristocracy lost men too, but all of a sudden when Adam delved and Eve span took on an existential poignance with a land fit for heroes, we get to think about that on November the 11th. Then we did it all again twenty years later and Britain was boracic lint, and many of those stately piles had been requisitioned for the military.
The aristocracy wittered, and bleated thusly: estate tax our stately homes to rebuild after the war OK, but we are yeoman farmers, so don’t tax agricultural land, lest it stop being passed from yeoman farmer to son. Labour presumably knew nothing about farming, so they fell for it. There aren’t any yeoman farmers in Britain, there weren’t then and there aren’t now, because much rural land ownership is in aristocratic dynasties ever since 1066, it’s not like the north forty in the USA. Agricultural relief has led to massive consolidation in land ownership, as have other adverse changes in farming practice.
It’s all bollocks. What happens is the aristocracy holds title to the land, claims ag relief to evade inheritance tax and pass the capital on to their scions free of estate duty, cuz agricultural, innit. These scions have zero interest in farming, agricultural land is merely a tax wheeze. They put it out to contract farmers. They only need preserve the capital, so these toffs squeeze the bejesus out of these contract farmers to rape the land, drench it in chemicals and spray noxious shit that drifts on the wind, and no, I’m not talking about good honest muck. This gets the aristocracy some return on capital, to the detriment of the environment, flooding of towns and cities as as much land is in production as possible.
One result is that the mineral content of food grown in the UK has dropped since 1940 along with the general issues of ruoff, pollution and algal blooms, but hey, Tarquin’s inheritance is safe. Now only up to £1M, which is about the same amount that Shanice in sarf London can inherit from her diligent cleaner parents in Lewisham, who bought their council house. Don’t see why farming pays IHT at 20% rather than 40% but it’s a step in the right direction.
In upland areas you get shooting estates, which I would eliminate for their bad attitude to mustelids, but they are also an environmental disgrace. Not content with persecuting mustelids, they illegally shoot some of our majestic birds of prey. So yeah, good start on aristocratic dynastic wealth, much work to be done.Expensive finance professionals will be drawing up trusts, shell companies, blind trusts to end-run this, so if we can have a law that no non-human entity can hold land in Britain without traceability to a responsible human as a matter of public record that might be a good start 😉 Go into any mayor’s office in France and you can inspect the cadastral records to know who owns what. Here in the UK we have the abomination of unregistered land.
Pensions as IHT scam stopped
On the subject of IHT apparently unused pensions will become part of the estate for IHT, removing a popular IHT-dodging scam which was an unintended consequence of Osborne’s pension reforms in 2016. I’m getting decent value for my £3k extra tax in seeing these guys taken out. Your pension, like your farm, was never designed to be an IHT evasion scheme.
I don’t personally give a toss about VAT on private/public schools – well, I’d raze the latter to the ground for being a major source of entitled pollution of the body politic, see last government for a worked example and the entitled incompetent git formerly known as Bozza for PM for a specific case. Neither sort should be charities, they are businesses providing a service in terms of Veblen goods, just like LVMH.
Curiously that blasted triple lock on pensions is retained, a link to inflation and to earnings is fair enough, but it’s time to switch off the escalator. Yes in principle I do benefit from it in future, but IMO it’s unsustainable and it’s also unfair. It’s done its job in lifting the state pension from a pittance and it’s time for the 2.5% part of the triple lock to retire.
Shifting things about – tax mitigation
I had expected dividend payments to be taxed like income, what with all this horny handed workers set against capitalist running dogs, but it was not to be, this time, leastways. While we’re at it it was a relief that the ISA allowance is retained. There is a cogent argument that only rich bastards can fill their ISAs – for perspective it’s nearly two thirds of the average UK net household income.
So it’s time to move things around between the ISA and the GIA. I have some things in the ISA for income, like some L&G shares and some renewables ITs. These do pay income, but capital gain, not so much. It would be rational to sell them to rebuy them into the GIA and sell my GIA world trackers, and perhaps some of the gold and rebuy in the ISA with the proceeds of the stuff I kicked out of it. Moving the gold out of the ISA was in hindsight a bad call too, but I’d rather have the gain and pay the tax than not have the gain. I have rolled forward CGT losses of 10k, they have just become twice as valuable today 😉
Okay. I get to pay more tax. Some people who expected to avoid IHT through various wheezes get to pay tax too, which is a good thing IMO. A million sods IHT-free should be good enough for anybody. If your kids need more than that to establish themselves in life then they’re not doing something right IMO. BTW given the human life cycle they probably need it before you are dead, so that’s a top fully legit way of giving any amount to your spawn IHT-free. Be no King Tut and give it away while you’re still alive, at least seven years before you kick the bucket.
If we’re really lucky some of that tax will make some things in Britain work less badly. I’ve seen rather a lot of the NHS this year, as a visitor, not a patient. In my non-expert opinion it’s on life support itself. In this expert’s opinion it’s in a critical condition, go figure.
You walk down the aisles in Tesco and you see all the fizzy drinks and energy drinks, and you can see that this fire is being stoked by capitalism. Nobody who is over a normal BMI need go within 100 yards of energy drinks. The NHS can’t beat that, that sort of shit needs to be regulated out of existence. It’s not the only cause of endemic sickness, but it would be a start.
Schools seem to be in a piss-poor shape too. State of the nation, SNAFU, that’s what 14 years of Tory rule do for you. I don’t see the prognosis as a resurgence, more managed decline. Britain is a poor society with a few rich people in it as this FT wag once said.
This is what decline looks like. If we must fall, let the fall be slow…